Acuity Scheduling vs Square Appointments
A detailed, unbiased comparison to help you choose the right scheduling software for your needs. Updated for 2026.
Key Takeaways
- Acuity Scheduling excels at: Extensive customization
- Square Appointments excels at: Free for single users
- Acuity Scheduling wins 4 out of 6 categories
- Acuity Scheduling is best for: Service businesses needing flexibility
- Square Appointments is best for: Businesses using Square for payments
Quick Overview
Acuity Scheduling
Acuity is a full-featured scheduling solution for service businesses with powerful customization options.
Pros
- Extensive customization
- Multiple payment processors
- Advanced intake forms
- Class and appointment scheduling
- Package and membership support
Cons
- No free plan
- Steeper learning curve
- Dated interface
Square Appointments
Square Appointments is a scheduling tool tied to the Square payment ecosystem, great for businesses already using Square POS.
Pros
- Free for single users
- Native Square payments
- POS integration
- Simple interface
- Instagram booking
Cons
- Locked to Square payments
- Limited video conferencing
- Basic features on free plan
- Less customization
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | Acuity | Square | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | No | Yes (1 user) | Square |
| Payment Flexibility | Multiple options | Square only | Acuity |
| Customization | Extensive | Limited | Acuity |
| POS Integration | Limited | Native | Square |
| Video Meetings | Good | Limited | Acuity |
| Class Scheduling | Excellent | Basic | Acuity |
“Started with Square Appointments because it was free with my Square payments. When I needed more features like packages and custom intake forms, SchedulingKit was the perfect upgrade without switching payment processors.”
Our Verdict
Square Appointments is best if you're already using Square for payments. Acuity offers more power and flexibility for growing service businesses. SchedulingKit gives you the best of both - multiple payment options and powerful features with an easy interface.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better overall, Acuity or Square?
In our feature-by-feature comparison, Acuity Scheduling came out ahead in 4 of 6 categories. That said, Square Appointments is specifically built for businesses using square for payments, so it can be the better choice if that matches your use case. There is no single "best" — it depends on your priorities.
What does Acuity cost compared to Square?
Acuity Scheduling pricing: $16-49/month. Square Appointments pricing: Free (1 user) / $29-69/month. Watch for extras — SMS reminders, payment processing, and additional team seats often add 30-50% to headline prices on both platforms.
What are the biggest drawbacks of Acuity?
Users commonly cite no free plan and steeper learning curve. If service businesses needing flexibility is not your primary need, those limitations may outweigh its strengths.
What are the biggest drawbacks of Square?
The most frequent complaints about Square Appointments include locked to square payments and limited video conferencing. For teams that need extensive customization, these gaps can be deal-breakers.
Can I switch from Acuity or Square to SchedulingKit?
Yes. You will need to recreate your event types and update booking links on your website and email signature, but calendar connections carry over through standard integrations. Most users complete the switch in under an hour. Our migration guides cover the process step by step.
Powerful scheduling without payment processor lock-in
Try SchedulingKit free and see why thousands of businesses are switching.
Free forever plan available • No credit card required